Crossword puzzle clue "one may be tarnished or upheld"

One may be tarnished or upheld

First player whose HR was reviewed (and upheld) by umpires using instant replay

She said, “Until 1972, no Supreme Court case ever upheld the claim of a woman in a gender discrimination case”

Upheld (objection)

"I noticed you use the ___ ___ often than the tarnished one"

Tarnished (reputation)

Tarnished

Tarnished