Here are the possible solutions for what our secret should be clue
Answer
Clue
Relevancy
betweenyouandme
Clue
What our secret should be
oslin
Clue
Grammy-winner K.T. whose ode "80's Ladies" claims "We burned our bras / And we burned our dinners / And we burned our candles at both ends" haha sounds like us
hesitant
Clue
Wondering "Should I? Should I not?"
Definition
tending to hold back
istay
Clue
"Should ___ or Should I Go"
mickjones
Clue
"Should I Stay or Should I Go" singer
stay
Clue
"Should I ___ or Should I Go" (1982 song by The Clash)