Crossword puzzle clue "what you might catch a tiger by in a saying"

What you might catch a tiger by, in a saying

Standard with the lyrics "Your eyes are always saying / the things you're never saying"

Verb you might still be saying instead of "DVR" if you're really old-school

“Cabaret” tune with the lyric “A tiger is a tiger, not a lamb”

You might rate them on their route and they might rate you on you vomited everywhere

Saying that often goes without saying

Baffles (ABOUT THIS PUZZLE: If you saw the headline "Fiend Found!" you might instantly notice that, between the two words, only the vowels change — the consonants stay put. Okay, if you were me, you'

"___, meeny, miney, moe, catch a tiger by the toe"